3. The Constitution is amended by inserting, immediately after Article 5, the following Articles:“Procedure for amending certain provisions establishing office of President, etc. |
5A.—(1) Subject to clause (2), a Bill seeking to amend any of the provisions mentioned in clause (7) cannot be introduced in Parliament unless —(a) | the President, acting in his discretion, concurs with the introduction of the Bill; or | (b) | the Government submits the Bill to a national referendum at which it is supported by more than half of the total number of votes cast by the electors registered under the Parliamentary Elections Act (Cap. 218). |
(2) Despite a refusal by the President to concur with the introduction of the Bill, the Bill can still be introduced in Parliament if the Council of Presidential Advisers had recommended to the President that he should concur with the introduction of the Bill. |
(3) Before the Government submits a Bill to a national referendum under clause (1)(b), the Government must, if the President’s concurrence for the introduction of the Bill was sought but refused, cause to be published in the Gazette both the President’s grounds as certified under Article 37IE(2)(a) and the recommendation of the Council of Presidential Advisers in relation to the introduction of the Bill. |
(4) Before a Bill is introduced under clause (2), the Government must —(a) | cause the President’s grounds, as certified under Article 37IE(2)(a), to be published in the Gazette; and | (b) | send the recommendation of the Council of Presidential Advisers in relation to the introduction of the Bill to the Speaker, who must present the recommendation to Parliament. |
|
(5) After a Bill is introduced under clause (1)(a) or (b) or (2), it can only be passed by Parliament if it is supported on Second and Third Readings by the votes of not less than two‑thirds of the total number of Members of Parliament (excluding nominated Members). |
(6) Subject to clause (5), if a Bill is introduced under clause (1)(b), the Bill can be amended during its passage through Parliament if the Speaker is of the opinion that the amendment is of a minor or purely drafting character or that the amendment does not affect the substance of the Bill that was supported at the national referendum. |
(7) The provisions mentioned by clause (1) are —(a) | this Article and Articles 5B (except clause (9)) and 5C; and | (b) | Articles 17(1) and (2), 17A, 20(1) and (2), 22K, 22L, 22N and 22O. |
|
|
Procedure for amending other provisions relating to office of President and certain discretionary powers of President |
5B.—(1) Subject to clauses (2) and (7), a Bill (other than a Bill to which Article 5A applies) seeking to amend clause (9) or any of the provisions mentioned in clause (9) cannot be introduced in Parliament unless —(a) | the President, acting in his discretion, concurs with the introduction of the Bill; or | (b) | the Government submits the Bill to a national referendum at which it is supported by more than half of the total number of votes cast by the electors registered under the Parliamentary Elections Act (Cap. 218). |
(2) Despite a refusal by the President to concur with the introduction of the Bill, the Bill can still be introduced in Parliament if the Council of Presidential Advisers had recommended to the President that he should concur with the introduction of the Bill. |
(3) Before the Government submits a Bill to a national referendum under clause (1)(b), the Government must, if the President’s concurrence for the introduction of the Bill was sought but refused, cause to be published in the Gazette both the President’s grounds as certified under Article 37IE(2)(a) and the recommendation of the Council of Presidential Advisers in relation to the introduction of the Bill. |
(4) Before a Bill is introduced under clause (2), the Government must —(a) | cause the President’s grounds, as certified under Article 37IE(2)(a), to be published in the Gazette; and | (b) | send the recommendation of the Council of Presidential Advisers in relation to the introduction of the Bill to the Speaker, who must present the recommendation to Parliament. |
|
(5) After a Bill is introduced under clause (1)(a) or (b) or (2), it can only be passed by Parliament if it is supported on Second and Third Readings by the votes of not less than two‑thirds of the total number of Members of Parliament (excluding nominated Members). |
(6) Subject to clause (5), if a Bill is introduced under clause (1)(b), the Bill can be amended during its passage through Parliament if the Speaker is of the opinion that the amendment is of a minor or purely drafting character or that the amendment does not affect the substance of the Bill that was supported at the national referendum. |
(7) If a Bill seeking to amend clause (9) or any of the provisions mentioned in that clause is not introduced pursuant to clause (1)(a) or (b) or (2), it can only be passed by Parliament if it is supported on Second and Third Readings by the votes of not less than three‑quarters of the total number of Members of Parliament (excluding nominated Members). |
(8) Before a Bill is introduced under clause (7), the Government must, if the President’s concurrence for the introduction of the Bill was sought but refused —(a) | cause the President’s grounds, as certified under Article 37IE(2)(a), to be published in the Gazette; and | (b) | send the recommendation of the Council of Presidential Advisers in relation to the introduction of the Bill to the Speaker, who must present the recommendation to Parliament. |
|
(9) The provisions mentioned by clause (1) are —(a) | clause (3) of Article 17 and the provisions mentioned in that clause; and | (b) | Articles 22F, 22H, 22J, 22M and 93A. |
|
|
Additional procedure for amendments that circumvent or curtail certain discretionary powers of President |
5C.—(1) In addition to Article 5(2), the President may, acting in his discretion, withhold his assent to any Bill seeking to amend this Constitution (other than a Bill to which Article 5A or 5B applies), if the Bill or any provision of the Bill provides, directly or indirectly, for the circumvention or curtailment of the discretionary powers conferred on the President by any provision mentioned in Article 5B(9).(2) The President may, on the advice of the Cabinet, refer to a tribunal pursuant to Article 100 (with any necessary modifications) the question whether a Bill seeking to amend this Constitution is one to which clause (1) applies, and such a reference may be made whether or not the President has purported to withhold his assent under clause (1). |
(3) If a Bill is referred under clause (2), the following provisions apply:(a) | if the tribunal is of the opinion that clause (1) does not apply to the Bill, the President is deemed to have assented to the Bill on the day the tribunal pronounces its opinion in open court (even if the President had earlier purported to withhold his assent under clause (1)); | (b) | if the tribunal is of the opinion that clause (1) applies to the Bill and the President had not earlier signified his decision on the Bill, the President may, acting in his discretion, withhold his assent to the Bill. |
|
(4) If the President withholds his assent to a Bill under clause (1) or (3)(b), the President is still deemed to have assented to the Bill —(a) | where the Council of Presidential Advisers has recommended that the President should withhold his assent to the Bill —(i) | if the Government submits the Bill to a national referendum at which it is supported by more than half of the total number of votes cast by the electors registered under the Parliamentary Elections Act (Cap. 218); or | (ii) | if Parliament affirms the Bill by a resolution passed by not less than three‑quarters of the total number of Members of Parliament (excluding nominated Members); or |
| (b) | where the Council of Presidential Advisers has recommended that the President should assent to the Bill, if Parliament affirms the Bill by a resolution passed by not less than two‑thirds of the total number of Members of Parliament (excluding nominated Members). |
|
(5) Before the Government submits a Bill to a national referendum under clause (4)(a)(i), the Government must cause to be published in the Gazette both the President’s grounds as certified under Article 37IE(2)(a) and the recommendation of the Council of Presidential Advisers in relation to the Bill. |
(6) Before a resolution to affirm a Bill under clause (4)(a)(ii) or (b) can be moved, the Government must —(a) | cause the President’s grounds, as certified under Article 37IE(2)(a), to be published in the Gazette; and | (b) | send the recommendation of the Council of Presidential Advisers in relation to the Bill to the Speaker, who must present the recommendation to Parliament. |
|
(7) For the purposes of clause (4), the President is deemed to have assented to the Bill —(a) | on the date on which the result of the national referendum is published in the Gazette; or | (b) | on the date on which Parliament affirms the Bill, |
as the case may be, even if a reference under clause (2) has not been made or is pending the tribunal’s opinion.”. |
|
|
|
|